Menu

Repair request vs. credit after the inspection: which to ask for

6 min read · Updated · By the Property Made Clear team

Ask for a repair when the item is a safety issue or something the buyer needs fixed before moving in, and ask for a credit when the buyer would rather choose the contractor and control the work. Most requests end up as a mix of both, decided item by item. Here’s how to make that call with your buyer, and how to word each one.

What’s the difference between a repair request and a credit?

Both come from the same place: the inspection report. After it arrives, the buyer’s agent sends the seller a written request before the inspection or due diligence deadline. For each item, the buyer can ask for one of three things:

  • A repair. The seller has the work done before closing, and the buyer checks it at the final walk-through.
  • A credit. The seller agrees to pay a set amount toward the buyer’s costs at closing, and the buyer arranges the work afterward.
  • A lower price. The purchase price itself goes down to reflect the work the house needs.

The seller can agree, counter or say no. As the American Society of Home Inspectors puts it, “the seller is not obligated to comply.” If the two sides can’t agree, the buyer’s options narrow to taking the house as it is or using their contract rights to walk away before the deadline.

Not every state’s form has always allowed both. Arizona REALTORS® notes that the October 2022 revision of its purchase contract removed the requirement that a buyer could only ask for repairs, so a buyer can now ask for a credit in the BINSR, and the seller has five days to respond. Check what your own state’s form allows.

When to ask the seller for repairs

A repair request usually makes the most sense for:

  • Safety items. A missing water heater discharge pipe, a double-tapped breaker, a missing carbon monoxide detector. These are often small jobs, and no one wants them waiting until after move-in.
  • Things the buyer needs on day one. Heat in winter, working plumbing, a roof that doesn’t leak.
  • Buyers short on cash after closing. A credit still leaves the buyer paying the contractor later. If the buyer won’t have money set aside for work right after closing, having the seller do it may be easier.

The trade-off is control. ASHI warns that a seller “may opt to complete the repairs as quickly or as cheaply as possible to move the transaction along.” Protect your buyer by asking for a licensed professional, and for receipts or invoices before closing. For bigger repairs, consider asking for the right to re-inspect.

See what your buyer would get.

A plain-English summary of the inspection, sorted by priority, with your notes and every item linked to its page.

See an example →

When a credit is the better choice

A credit tends to work better when:

  • The buyer cares how it’s done. ASHI notes that a credit gives the buyer “greater control over the project,” from picking the contractor to choosing materials.
  • The work can’t be finished before closing. Contractors may not be available in time, or the job may need permits.
  • The buyer plans to redo the area anyway. There’s little point in the seller patching a bathroom the buyer will remodel.
  • The seller would rather not manage contractors. An out-of-state owner or an estate may say yes to a credit faster than to a repair.

The catch: a credit needs a number. Ask for too little and your buyer pays the difference. Ask for a round number with nothing behind it and the seller is likely to counter. That’s why estimates matter so much here (more on that below).

When to ask for a lower price instead

For very large items, such as a roof replacement or major foundation work, a price reduction may be the cleaner way to go. Loans limit how much a seller can contribute to the buyer’s costs and what that money can pay for, so a large credit can run into the loan’s limit. A lower price doesn’t have that problem.

Choose item by item
Ask for a repair

Best when: Safety items, or anything the buyer needs working on move-in day.

Ask for a licensed pro and receipts before closing.

Ask for a credit

Best when: The buyer wants to pick the contractor, or the work can’t be done before closing.

Needs a number: get estimates first. Check the lender’s limits.

Ask for a lower price

Best when: Very large items, like a roof replacement.

Useful when a credit would go over the loan’s limit.

Talk to the lender before you promise the seller anything. The limits depend on the loan type, the down payment and whether the home will be the buyer’s main residence, and FHA, VA and conventional loans each have their own rules. Our guide on writing a repair request covers the conventional-loan limits in more detail. Ask the lender, too, whether anything on your list would need to be fixed before the loan can close.

How to word each one

Vague requests cause most of the arguments later. For each item, name the problem, point to its page in the report and say exactly what you’re asking for.

Example wording

Repair: “Water heater has no discharge pipe on its pressure-relief valve (report page 5). Seller to have a licensed plumber install the discharge pipe, with invoice provided before closing.”

Credit: “Leak and soft flooring around the hall bathroom toilet (report page 7). Seller to credit buyer [amount] toward closing costs, per the attached plumbing estimate.”

Price: “Buyer and seller agree to reduce the purchase price by [amount] in lieu of the foundation repairs noted on report pages 9–10, per the attached engineer’s report and estimate.”

Use the form your contract calls for, and check the wording with your broker. A calm, factual tone helps: you’re describing what the inspector found, not judging the seller’s upkeep.

Back it up with estimates

Estimates help whichever way you go. For a credit, they set the number. For a repair, they show the seller the job is reasonable, and give your buyer something to compare if the seller offers a credit instead. ASHI describes the sequence simply: “Once a repair estimate is received, the buyer can ask the seller to credit the repair costs.”

Deadlines are short, so ask for estimates the day the report arrives, starting with the most expensive items. Our guide on getting repair estimates before the inspection deadline walks through it step by step. A rough number from the internet is a starting point, not something to put in a contract.

A faster way to build the list

Property Made Clear handles the slowest part. Upload the inspector’s PDF and your buyer gets a plain-English summary on their phone, sorted into before-closing priorities, first-year items and routine upkeep, with every item linked to its page in the report. That makes it easier to sit down together and decide repair, credit or price for each one.

Your buyer can also tap Get quote on any item to request free, no-obligation estimates from local pros, so your credits have real numbers behind them. It’s free for agents. See an example summary or read how it works for agents.

This guide is general information, not professional advice. For anything specific to your home, talk with your home inspector or a licensed professional.

Keep reading

Give your next buyer a report they’ll actually read.

Free for agents. No credit card needed.